Most councils mark the quality questions in a care tender on a scale of 0 to 5. A 3 usually means the answer meets the requirement. A 5 means the panel is confident you will deliver this contract, for these people, well. On a tender where quality carries most of the marks, the gap between those two numbers across ten questions is usually the gap between winning and coming second.
I've sat on the other side of the table, marking these answers. What separates a 3 from a 5 is rarely the size of the organisation or the polish of the writing. It comes down to three things.
1. Do you understand the people, not just the service?
The first thing I look for is whether the provider understands the client group on a human level.
A lot of organisations are very service-led. They know how to build systems: policies, procedures, care plans, rotas, audits. All of that matters, and a 3 answer usually has it. What a 3 answer often lacks is the emotional side: what it is actually like to be the person receiving this service.
A young person moving into supported accommodation at 16 isn't a referral to be processed. They may be leaving the only placement that has worked, frightened of being on their own, and testing whether the adults around them will stay. An older person starting home care may be losing some independence for the first time and feel it every time a stranger lets themselves in. A 5 answer shows that the writer knows this, and that their service is designed around it.
So the question to ask of every answer is: does this description speak to the people the council is buying the service for? If you swapped the client group for a different one, would the answer still read the same? If it would, it's a 3.
2. Is there a real plan, step by step?
The second thing is the plan. How exactly will this organisation deliver this contract?
A 3 answer tells me what the provider will do: "We will recruit experienced staff and ensure a smooth transition." A 5 answer tells me how, in what order, by when, and who is responsible: who leads the mobilisation, what happens in week one, how the first referrals are matched, what the manager checks at the end of the first month, and what happens if something slips.
The panel is trying to picture your service running. The more of the picture you give them, the less they have to take on trust, and trust is exactly what a score is measuring.
3. Are you honest about the gaps?
The third thing surprises people: I look for honesty.
Every organisation has shortcomings. You may be new to this council, new to this client group, or growing faster than your management structure. The weaker answers hide that and hope nobody notices. Evaluators do notice, and it costs you, because an answer that claims to have no gaps isn't believable.
The strongest answers name the gap and then show the plan to close it: "We haven't delivered in this borough before, so in the first three months we will…". That level of honesty is great to read. It tells the panel you know your own service, and that you'll tell the council the truth when something goes wrong after the contract starts, which is what they're really buying.
Two quick checks before you submit
Answer the question asked. Read the question and the scoring guidance again, then read your answer as if you'd never seen your organisation before. Every part of the question should be answered, in the order it's asked, using the council's own words where it helps the evaluator find them.
Say how often. "We review care plans regularly" scores lower than "Care plans are reviewed with the person every six weeks, and within 48 hours of any incident". Numbers, frequencies and named roles turn a promise into a plan.
A 3 and a 5, side by side
A specimen for a fictional provider, Harbour Lane Support. The question: "Describe how you will support young people aged 16 and 17 to settle into their accommodation."
Likely to score 3
"Harbour Lane Support has a robust admissions procedure. Each young person receives an induction pack and is allocated a key worker. A support plan is completed within 28 days and reviewed regularly. Staff are trained in trauma-informed practice."
Likely to score 5
"Moving in is often the point where a young person expects things to go wrong again, so we plan the first week around them rather than our paperwork. Before the move, their key worker visits them where they are now, and they choose one thing for their room. On day one the key worker is on shift from arrival until bedtime. We agree the support plan with the young person in their first fortnight, not 28 days, because that is when they decide whether to trust us. The key worker meets them weekly for the first three months, and the manager checks each plan at day 14 and day 42. We haven't supported 16 to 17-year-olds in this borough before, so in the first three months we will meet the leaving care team monthly to make sure our plans match theirs."
The second answer isn't longer because it's padded. It's longer because it shows the people, the plan and the gaps.
Want to check your own draft? Our free evaluator's checklist covers the 12 commonest ways answers lose marks.
Got a tender coming up?
If you've got a 3 you'd like to turn into a 5, we can help you win it. If you're setting up a new service, or want to keep the contract you have, we do that too. Book a short scoping call and tell us what you're working on.